Arguments Against International Trade
In this video, we discuss some of the most common arguments against international trade. Does trade harm workers by reducing the number of jobs in the U.S.? Is it
In this video, we discuss some of the most common arguments against international trade. Does trade harm workers by reducing the number of jobs in the U.S.? Is it wrong to trade with countries that use child labor? Is it important to keep a certain number of jobs at home for national security reasons? Can strategic protectionism increase well-being in the U.S.? Join us as we discuss these common concerns.
Contributed Content (0)
Ask a Question
Do your calculations on the costs and benefits of free trade in the internet age take into account the potential cost of future wars caused when another major power cuts off our supply of imported goods? Most wars were fought over resources.
Actually the evidence is that free trade reduces war. See The Invisible Hand of Peace. http://www.amazon.com/Invisible-Hand-Peace-Capitalism-International/dp/0...
I will ask you the same question I asked Thomas Sowell about 10 years ago that impacted his writings on immigration and globalism. 1. How many economics professors are hurt by free trade? 2. What exact jobs will the millions of low skill US workers perform? Give examples. Not just graphs, please.
The economics profession is very open to competition from abroad--there are very few barriers, for example, to hire an Econ PhD from anywhere in the world and most departments have lots of foreign born PhDs on staff. Thus, competition from abroad for American economists has been very high. In essence, there is free trade in Econ PhDs. Whether this has hurt American PhDs I don't know but it has probably pushed wages down.
Most jobs today are in the service sector and it is here that American low skill workers can outcompete foreign low skill workers. It is, of course, true that low skill workers everywhere tend to earn low wages.
The application of more education can only go so far. How does one educate a person with an IQ of 85 to do some "high skill" job that often requires knowledge of technology, rather than an aqquired trade such as welding or sewing?
Low-skilled workers will always be needed. Welding is a high skilled job that is not easy to learn. I found it difficult. I teach agriculture, economics, and answer questions about taxes. That is my comparative advantage. Some welders are very highly paid. I cannot tell you about sewing. Some do not benefit as much from education. You are correct However, rich and poor alike benefit form the lower prices of goods because of competition. A person with below average intelligence may not be able to do anything as well as you do. However, it still benefits you to trade with that person because of comparative advantage. As you get better in what you have the greatest comparative advantage, the value of the less-skilled worker's comparative advantage increases. You do not want to work in the area where the low-skilled worker does. The opportunity cost of your labor is too high. Therefore, you will be willing to pay more for the product of the low-skilled worker's labor. When your skills increase, both you and the low-skilled worker are better off.